In Greece, Easter eggs are traditionally dyed red to symbolize the blood of Christ. Bowls of red eggs are set out in homes during the Holy Week, and after the Anastasi (the Resurrection of Christ, celebrated at midnight on the night before Easter Sunday) they are eaten with some fanfare.

The ritual is a game; people will try to crack each other’s eggs using their own, and whoever holds the last intact egg wins (see the rules to this seemingly banal, but often quite competitive and fun game here). 

While tradition calls for red eggs, thanks to influences from abroad (and Pinterest), other colors have also been showing up on Greek Easter tables lately. And some crafty home economists have taken to making their own dyes using vegetables – an alternative that seems both healthier and, honestly, more fun than using the chemical-rich kits sold at the supermarkets.

But can you really get decent results using only vegetables? Or will you end up with the dyed egg version of a veggie-burger – certainly a healthier alternative but ultimately a fun-sapping disappointment. I decided to test run four variations of homemade dyes and see which work (so you don’t have to).

The Hypothesis

The internet and my mother in law suggest that: onion peel dye and beet dye should turn the eggs red or pink, cabbage dye should turn them blue, and turmeric dye should turn them yellow.

I chose to use the dyes on both white and brown eggs, to get as many color variations as possible. I expected the brown ones to turn gorgeous deep colors, and the white ones to get lighter, pastel shades, and I was kind of right. What I didn’t expect was the amount of variations I would actually get.

The Results

The white eggs did indeed turn pastel pink, blue, and yellow – pretty much as expected. The brown eggs on the other hand, while getting darker and deeper colors, also ended up with a lot more blemishes. When patting the dye off some of the brown eggs, the color would come off in many places, leaving the eggs looking freckled – kind of like naturally speckled eggs.

According to ye olde internet, tiny imperfections like unnoticeable cracks and particles stuck to the shells can cause splotchy eggs, so the spots on my brown eggs probably had less to do with their color, and more to do with their quality. To prevent spots, handle eggs carefully and rinse and wipe each egg after cooking. If you do end up with freckled eggs – stay positive, they’re still pretty.

In general, natural dyes are a bit unpredictable. I learned that the same dye can turn one egg soft pink, and another almost purple. What’s lovely about it is that you get a range of unique looking eggs that carry much more character than a bowl of uniform red eggs.

Another thing I didn’t expect was the disappointing results of the onion peel dye. Since it is the most famous of the natural dyes I tried, I expected a good outcome and rich, rusty-red colored eggs. However, the white eggs just came out looking like brown eggs, and the brown eggs turned… a little browner. Thumbs down.

To poach the recipes I did like (get the yolk?), see below.

How to make natural dyes for eggs:

I made each of these dyes using 1 cup of water, which makes enough dye to soak 1-2 eggs at a time. Glass jars are great for dyeing a few eggs. To soak a batch of up to 12 eggs all at once, make at least 4 times the amount of dye.

For all the dyes, the eggs come first: Cook yours and let them cool. They should be hard-boiled.

To dye them, carefully place your eggs in the dye and then practice patience. Moving the eggs around in the dye or touching them before the color has really set may leave marks. Some dyes are strong enough to color your eggs within seconds or minutes, while other dyes need several hours. To make sure all your eggs take up as much color as possible, place the jars of dye and eggs in the refrigerator overnight. I experimented with the time for each dye. You can read about my results below.

After dying your eggs, carefully pat them down with paper towels, and leave them on a cooling rack to dry completely for a couple of hours. Then rub each egg with a few drops of vegetable oil to add shine.

Remember: wear plastic gloves to avoid staining your fingers. If attempting this with kids, I’d also recommend aprons.